• free bets no deposit 2019
free bets no deposit 2019The League of Nerds
Got a question? Ask a nerd!
  • League Members
  • Send a Question
  • Join the League
  • Home
  • The Language Nerd
  • O Wretched Tongue!
The Weirdness of Th
The Alphabet to Beat All Alphabets

free login royal panda reviews_Welfare offer mega casino bonus codes 2019_Welfare offer betfred live

January 22, 2013 Written by The Language Nerd
Seal tongue

Seal with wretched tongue (Photo credit: @Doug88888)

Dear Language Nerd,Why do we say stretched, fetched, and retched, but wretchèd?

-Delphine Sultzer

***

Dear Delphine,

Because the first three are verbs and the last one’s an adjective. English has a lot of rules (shocking, I know) about pronunciation. We lucky native speakers use them all the time without ever realizing, and the regular-past-tense-ending rule is one of the better ones, because it’s one of two English rules I can think of that have clear-cut categories and no exceptions. Adjectives, which we’ll get to later, are something else again.

So, all those many many words that end with a written <ed> (recall the EFLN? <> for shapes, // for sounds) get pronounced in one of three ways:

fetched, stopped, pushed, baked
visited, landed
grabbed, buzzed, cried, bugged

Usually, <ed> is pronounced /t/ or /d/. /t/ and /d/ make up one of those voiceless/voiced pairs we talked about last time, and they come after voiceless and voiced sounds, respectively. (If you put your hand to your throat and make a voiced sound, like /v/, you can feel your vocal chords vibrate. If you make a voiceless sound, like /f/, you won’t feel anything. Well, your lips might get tingly, I suppose.) We tend to think of <ed> as having an /?d/ sound, but it’s only said that way when the verb stem itself ends with /t/ or /d/, and we need to add a whole syllable to make the past sound clear (because who wants to try pronouncing /land?d/ as /landd/?).

So we have
— ? ? an /id/ sound after /t/ and /d/
— ? ? a /t/ sound after /p/, /s/, /k/, /?/*, /t?/**, /h/, /θ/, and /f/
—? ?? and a /d/ sound after eveything else.***

*This is the symbol for <sh>
** This is the symbol for <ch>, /t/ and /?/ together. Try it — say “t” and “sh” at the same time and you’ll end up with “ch”
***I say “everything else” as opposed to listing because there are waaay more voiced sounds than voiceless. /r/ and /m/, for example, have no goateed voiceless evil twin, and all of our twenty-odd vowels are voiced.

So, okay, past-tense pronunciation is kind of an odd rule, or at least it’s odd to think about it if you’ve never realized the ways you’re dividing up sounds subconsciously, but it’s a reasonable rule. A learnable rule. A rule that is, in fact, a rule, and not just a mess. And now we come to adjectives.

The problem is that so many adjectives are based on the past participle. We start with “I surprised him with a delicious cake!”, move to “He was surprised by its extreme deliciousness!” and end up with “The surprised lad ate the whole cake by himself, much to our chagrin.” So sometimes — often! — we have adjectives based on verbs that follow the regular past-tense verb pronunciation rules.

And it can be very hard to distinguish between participles and straight adjectives. “Wretched,” for example, is currently only an adjective (since its mother verb, wreccan “to drive out, to punish,” ran off to become “wreak”), so “the wretched man” has only an adjective in front of it, same as “the blue mouse.” But what about “the heavy-lidded kitten”? “The well-wrapped present”? “The jumped-upon quarterback”? Where and how do we draw the line? Linguists will argue about this ALL DAY LONG, I promise you.

The real difficulty is that occasionally we will go through a phase of wanting to differentiate between our verbs and our adjectives, and then someone always gets hurt. This is why we have a pile of verbs and adjectives that are spelled the same, but while the verbs follow the usual trifecta of rules, the adjectives are pronounced with /?d/ no matter what sound they follow:

Those socks just wicked the sweat away! / The wickèd witch is dead!
Have you learned nothing? / The learnèd professor peered through her pince-nez.
She cursed her to speak only in limericks. / Let’s get away from this cursèd place!
We legged it for the nearest shelter. / The three-leggèd princess’s song rang across the moor.

There’s no good rule for when these pronunciations will be different and when, like “I surprised him”/”the surprised lad” they will be the same. Like many past participle forms themselves (eat-ate-eaten? really, guys?) they just have to be memorized in lists, by which I mean absorbed naturally over time if you speak English as your first language. USA! USA! USA!

Don’t be too angry with English spelling, really. We sacrifice phonological information for morphological and etymological information — if we spelled all these past tenses with the sound they make, their connection wouldn’t be as obvious on the page. Though this is no excuse for our <ough> trouble.

By the way, the other pronunciation rule with clear-cut categories and no exceptions? Cats, maps, backs, baths, muffs; kisses, wishes, watches, quizzes; dogs, buns, gobs, waves.

Yours,

The Language Nerd

Got a language question? Ask the Language Nerd! asktheleagueofnerds@gmail.com
Or: Twitter @AskTheLeague / facebook.com/asktheleagueofnerds

A lot of intro to phonology textbooks use the past tense as the first exercise, to get students thinking about sounds instead of spelling. What I had handy was the excellent reference book Practical English Usage by Michael Swan. And, of course, found out about wreccan through etymonline.

Brought to you by the League of Nerds

The Language Nerd
Adjective, English, language, Participle, past tense, pronunciation
Similar posts
  • Silent (But Deadly) E — Our son Anthony is in First grade and has spelling tests on Fridays from his weekly list. I’m mostly a musician but love to help him with his spelling by telling him the history of the letter K for example. Our question is this: Why do we not pronounce all the written syllables in the [...]
  • Everything You Know About Grammar is Bullsh%^t, Part 2 — Last post I mostly just groused about how little grammar most people know. Today, in an attempt at a more useful follow-up, I’ll go over the basic categories of words in English, which you may have learned as the “parts of speech.” I’m drawing from and drastically simplifying Rodney Huddleston and Geoffrey Pullum’s A Student’s [...]
  • The Feeling’s Mutual — Language Nerd, Spanish and French were once both dialects of Latin, but now they’re different languages… when did they switch from 2 dialects of one language to 2 languages? *** Dear mysterious anonymous person, When Spanish and French people stopped being able to understand each other. Since I’ve been calling myself the Language Nerd for [...]
  • Useful Turkish Phrases — Hey Language Nerd, I’m about to head to Turkey to visit my goofy sister and was hoping for a bit of help. Can you craft a list of useful phases (how to be polite, purchase things, and whatnot)? I don’t want to just hop on over there and be a total goober to the locals. [...]
  • Fancy-Shmancy Reduplication — Dear Language Nerd, Duplication I get, sure, but what’s up with reduplication? -Carl S., Jr. *** Dear Carl, Reduplication is when sounds or words are said twice in a row. In English, we have a few set words that use reduplication — frou-frou, razzle-dazzle, bye-bye — that sort of thing. We also have the more [...]
The Weirdness of Th
The Alphabet to Beat All Alphabets

2 Pings/Trackbacks

  1. Pairing Off | The League of Nerds on July 16, 2013 at 8:30 pm
  2. The League of Nerds – Pairing Off on January 18, 2014 at 11:44 am

Top Posts

  • Eggcorns, Malapropisms, and Mondegreens
  • Everything You Know About Grammar is Bullsh%^t, Part 2
  • Electromagnetic Fork Flinger
  • Fifty Shades of White
  • Talk Like a Monster
  • How Ya Like My Essay on Criticism Now?
  • The Heartbeat Goes On
  • The Curious Linguistics of the Doge in the Internet

The Nerds

  • Special Guest Nerds
  • The Art Nerd
  • The Biology Nerd
  • The Electromagnetics Nerd
  • The Language Nerd
  • The Paramedics Nerd

Nerds on Twitter

My Tweets

Nerds on Facebook

Nerds on Facebook

Nerds on Emails

Archives

  • June 2017
  • February 2017
  • December 2016
  • October 2016
  • August 2016
  • July 2016
  • June 2016
  • May 2016
  • April 2016
  • March 2016
  • February 2016
  • January 2016
  • December 2015
  • November 2015
  • October 2015
  • September 2015
  • August 2015
  • July 2015
  • June 2015
  • May 2015
  • April 2015
  • March 2015
  • February 2015
  • January 2015
  • December 2014
  • November 2014
  • October 2014
  • September 2014
  • August 2014
  • July 2014
  • June 2014
  • May 2014
  • April 2014
  • March 2014
  • February 2014
  • January 2014
  • December 2013
  • November 2013
  • October 2013
  • September 2013
  • August 2013
  • July 2013
  • June 2013
  • May 2013
  • April 2013
  • March 2013
  • February 2013
  • January 2013
  • December 2012
  • free bets no deposit 2019